Felicity Reynolds (Jennings Rice) is a woman with a past she can’t outrun. After discovering the brutal murder of her wealthy client at the exclusive spa where she works, she becomes the prime suspect in a small town that’s all too eager to point the finger. With her vengeful ex-boyfriend closing in and the police hot on her trail, Felicity has no choice but to flee to the last place on earth she wants to be: the Atlanta home of her estranged sister, Erin (Katelin Chesna). But the safety of family is an illusion.

As Felicity tries to piece together the clues to clear her name, she uncovers a nest of secrets deeper than she imagined. Everyone is a suspect—her sister’s suspicious husband, the victim’s shady business partners, and even the seemingly supportive new friends she meets. In a race against time, Felicity must untangle a deadly web of blackmail and betrayal before the real killer silences her for good, proving that you can never truly trust anyone.

---

Trust Her If You Dare cast photos

1. Jennings Rice as Felicity Reynolds

Felicity is a master of reinvention, but her new life as an esthetician shatters when she finds her client’s body. Rice portrays her as a resilient survivor, whose flight instinct is matched only by her fierce determination to uncover the truth. Her intimate knowledge of the spa’s elite clientele and their secrets becomes her only weapon, but using it forces her to confront the dark history she was trying to escape.

Rice embodies Felicity’s journey from terrified fugitive to empowered sleuth. Her performance is a physical one, conveying sheer panic in silent glances and the calculated calm of someone who knows how to hide in plain sight, making her the ultimate unreliable narrator you can’t help but root for.

2. Katelin Chesna as Erin Novak

Erin’s seemingly perfect suburban life is upended when her estranged sister arrives on her doorstep covered in blood and begging for help. Chesna masterfully portrays a woman torn between familial duty and deep-seated resentment. Her hospitality is laced with suspicion, and as Felicity’s presence threatens her family’s stability, Erin is forced to choose between protecting her sister or protecting the life she’s built.

Chesna brings a layered vulnerability to Erin, whose own secrets make her an unwilling accomplice and a potential target. Her character’s arc is a central mystery, making the audience question whether she is Felicity’s greatest ally or her most dangerous foe.

3. Carlo Marks as Darren Malone

Darren is Felicity’s dangerously obsessive ex-boyfriend, a man from her past who refuses to let her go. Marks oozes menacing charm, tracking Felicity with a possessive fury that suggests he knows more about the murder than he lets on. His sudden reappearance in Atlanta confirms Felicity’s worst fears: she will never be free of him.

Marks creates a villain who is both terrifying and strangely pathetic, a toxic combination of love and rage. His character’s motivations remain shrouded in mystery, keeping viewers guessing whether he is the killer, a red herring, or a catalyst for the film’s shocking final twist.

4. Michael Stiggers as Connor Novak

Connor, Erin’s husband, is immediately hostile to Felicity’s intrusion. Stiggers portrays him as a man fiercely protective of his family’s safety and status, his anger masking his own clandestine dealings. His financial troubles and connections to the victim’s business empire make him a prime suspect with a compelling motive.

Stiggers adds a layer of suburban menace to the role. Connor’s controlling nature and secretive behavior constantly put him at odds with Felicity, creating a powder keg of domestic tension that threatens to explode at any moment.

5. Angelique Valentine as Leighton Novak

Leighton, Erin and Connor’s perceptive teenage daughter, sees the cracks in her family’s facade that the adults work so hard to hide. Valentine brings a refreshing honesty to the role, becoming an unexpected confidante for Felicity. Her keen observations and tech-savvy skills prove crucial in hacking into the digital alibis of the suspects.

Valentine’s performance provides both heart and suspense. Leighton’s curiosity quickly puts her in the crosshairs, turning her from a quiet observer into a key player in the deadly game, and raising the stakes for Felicity exponentially.

6. Daniel Stine as Joshua Lemke

Joshua Lemke is the victim’s ambitious and ruthless business partner. Stine embodies corporate avarice, portraying a man who stood to gain everything from his partner’s death. His slick, polished demeanor hides a capacity for cold-blooded calculation, and he emerges as a suspect who is every bit as dangerous as a knife-wielding killer.

Stine’s performance is a masterclass in quiet threat. Joshua uses his power and influence to manipulate the investigation from afar, making him a formidable enemy who operates from the safety of a corner office.

7. Kristen Grace Gonzalez as Britney Davis

Britney, a fellow employee at the spa, was Felicity’s only friend. Gonzalez plays her with a bubbly exterior that conceals her own envy and ambition. She provides Felicity with key information about the victim’s personal life, but her sudden nervousness suggests she knows more than she’s telling.

Gonzalez makes Britney a perfect frenemy—seemingly helpful but ultimately out for herself. Her character’s shifting loyalties keep Felicity and the audience guessing about who can truly be trusted.

8. Christian Blaque Meier as Robert

Robert is a mysterious figure from Felicity’s past who reemerges in Atlanta, offering help with unclear motives. Meier brings a calm, imposing presence to the role, serving as either a guardian angel or a darker omen. His knowledge of Felicity’s secrets makes him a wild card who could swing the investigation in any direction.

Meier’s character embodies the theme that the past is never truly dead. Robert’s connection to Felicity’s old life forces her to confront the person she used to be, adding depth to her quest for redemption.

9. Annette Saunders as Loretta Johnson

Loretta is the no-nonsense, seasoned detective leading the murder investigation. Saunders brings a weary gravitas to the role, pursuing Felicity with a dogged determination that is both professional and personal. She sees through the lies and theatrics, but her own preconceptions about Felicity’s past threaten to blind her to the real killer.

Saunders provides a formidable intellectual opponent for Felicity. Detective Johnson’s cat-and-mouse game with our protagonist drives the investigative tension, as each piece of evidence she uncovers brings her closer to a truth that could condemn an innocent woman.

10. Gregory M. Mitchell as The Investor

This silent, powerful figure lurks in the background of the victim’s financial dealings. Mitchell’s brief but impactful presence suggests a world of corruption and high-stakes deals that went terribly wrong. His threat is implied rather than shown, representing the faceless, wealthy interests that will stop at nothing to protect their investments.

Mitchell’s role, though small, is crucial in expanding the scope of the mystery beyond a simple crime of passion, hinting at a conspiracy that makes the murder seem like a mere business transaction.