The Hearts Around the Table franchise returns with its most heartwarming installment yet! Josh’s Third Serving premieres April 5, 2025, on Hallmark Channel, bringing back fan-favorite characters and introducing new faces to the charming world of Maplewood. This time, chef Josh Adler faces his biggest challenge yet—balancing his booming restaurant, evolving friendships, and a surprise romance that could change everything. Packed with the series’ signature blend of small-town charm, delectable dishes, and emotional moments, this sequel promises to be the perfect comfort watch.
Leading the ensemble is Jake Epstein as Josh, whose everyman appeal and culinary passion anchor the story. He’s joined by Stephanie Bennett as Ella, whose chemistry with Josh has kept fans rooting for them since the first film. With returning stars like Mindy Cohn and Steve Lund, plus exciting newcomers like Mishael Morgan and Justice James, this cast serves up a perfect mix of nostalgia and fresh energy. Whether you’re here for the food, the romance, or the cozy community vibes, Josh’s Third Serving is a feel-good feast you won’t want to miss.
Hearts Around the Table: Josh’s Third Serving: Faces Behind the Show
1. Jake Epstein as Josh Adler
Jake Epstein reprises his role as Josh Adler, the big-hearted chef whose culinary talents and emotional journey have made him a Hallmark fan favorite. Since Degrassi and Designated Survivor, Epstein has perfected the art of playing relatable, kind-hearted heroes, and Josh is no exception. This installment sees him grappling with newfound success—should he expand his restaurant or preserve its intimate charm? Epstein’s warmth and everyman charm make Josh’s dilemmas feel deeply personal.
Off-screen, Epstein has become synonymous with Hallmark’s most beloved characters, and his dedication to the role shines through. From training with real chefs to perfecting Josh’s signature dishes, he brings authenticity to every scene. Fans can expect plenty of heart-tugging moments as Josh navigates love, ambition, and the meaning of home.
2. Stephanie Bennett as Ella Hawthorne
Stephanie Bennett returns as Ella Hawthorne, the spirited food critic whose chemistry with Josh has kept fans swooning. Bennett, known for Supernatural and A Christmas in Royal Fashion, infuses Ella with wit, intelligence, and a touch of vulnerability. This season, their relationship takes an unexpected turn when Ella’s career ambitions clash with her feelings for Josh. Bennett’s ability to balance romantic tension with independent spirit makes Ella a standout heroine.
Bennett’s real-life passion for food (she’s an avid home baker) adds authenticity to her scenes critiquing Josh’s dishes. Whether she’s trading playful barbs with Josh or facing her own professional crossroads, Bennett ensures Ella remains as compelling as ever. Will she and Josh finally find their perfect recipe for love?
3. Mindy Cohn as Angie Hartman
Mindy Cohn (The Facts of Life, Dolly Parton’s Heartstrings) steals every scene as Angie, Josh’s blunt but loving mentor. Cohn’s impeccable comedic timing and heartwarming delivery make Angie the voice of reason—and the source of many laughs. This time, Angie faces her own subplot involving a surprise from her past, allowing Cohn to showcase both her humor and dramatic chops.
Cohn’s chemistry with Epstein feels authentically mentor-mentee, full of tough love and mutual respect. Her character’s iconic one-liners (“Honey, even bad reviews are just someone’s opinion—usually someone wrong”) have become fan favorites. Angie’s journey this season adds depth to the franchise’s cozy world.
4. Kathryn Davis as Kiki Mercer
Kathryn Davis (When Calls the Heart) charms as Kiki, Ella’s bubbly best friend and the town’s resident event planner. Davis brings effervescent energy to Kiki, whether she’s orchestrating Maplewood’s festivals or nudging Ella toward romance. This season, Kiki gets her own romantic subplot with a mysterious newcomer, giving Davis chances to shine in both comedic and heartfelt moments.
Davis’s background in improv lends spontaneity to Kiki’s quirky antics. Her friendship with Bennett’s Ella feels lived-in and supportive, a testament to their off-screen bond. Kiki’s infectious optimism makes her the emotional glue of Maplewood.
5. Ashley Newbrough as Jenna Whitaker
Ashley Newbrough (Spun Out, The Bold Type) returns as Jenna, Josh’s ex who’s now a supportive friend. Newbrough’s nuanced performance avoids clichés, showing Jenna’s genuine happiness for Josh while hinting at lingering what-ifs. Her scenes with Epstein crackle with unresolved history, adding tension to the group dynamic.
Newbrough’s portrayal makes Jenna more than just a plot device—she’s a fully realized character with her own arc. This season, Jenna considers leaving Maplewood, forcing Josh to confront how much their friendship means.
6. Steve Lund as Andrew Clarington
Steve Lund (Schitt’s Creek, Christmas in Evergreen) brings roguish charm to Andrew, Josh’s friendly rival and fellow restaurateur. Lund’s natural charisma makes Andrew likable even when he’s (playfully) undermining Josh. Their competitive banter (“My special’s selling better than yours—admit it”) is a series highlight.
This season, Andrew softens as he mentors a young chef (Justice James’ Rory), showing Lund’s range. His redemption arc—from antagonist to ally—has been one of the franchise’s most satisfying evolutions.
7. Mishael Morgan as Shari Adams
The Young and the Restless star Mishael Morgan joins the cast as Shari, a no-nonsense food blogger who shakes up Maplewood’s dining scene. Morgan’s commanding presence and sharp wit make Shari an instant foil for Josh and Ella. Her critiques (“This risotto is… brave”) spark both laughter and growth.
Morgan’s dramatic background adds gravitas to Shari’s layers—beneath her tough exterior lies a secret passion for baking. Her chemistry with Lund’s Andrew suggests a potential romantic spark.
8. Justice James as Rory Nelson
Rising star Justice James plays Rory, an ambitious young cook who idolizes Josh. James brings youthful energy and raw talent to the role, making Rory’s journey from insecure newbie to confident chef inspiring. His mentorship scenes with Epstein and Lund are heartwarming highlights.
James, a real-life culinary school graduate, trained extensively for the role. His character’s bond with Millie Davis’ Gina adds sweet, youthful romance to the story.
With its perfect blend of romance, humor, and small-town charm, Hearts Around the Table: Josh’s Third Serving is Hallmark comfort food at its finest. Don’t miss the premiere April 5, 2025!
