Premiering March 8, 2025, on Lifetime, I Was Octomom: The Natalie Suleman Story is a compelling and emotional biopic that delves into the life of Natalie Suleman, the woman who became a global sensation after giving birth to octuplets in 2009. The film explores the challenges, controversies, and personal struggles that followed her unprecedented journey into the spotlight. With its mix of drama, heartbreak, and resilience, this Lifetime original offers an intimate look at one of the most talked-about stories of the 21st century.
From the pressures of raising 14 children to the media frenzy that surrounded her, I Was Octomom sheds light on the human side of a story that captivated the world. Featuring a talented cast and a powerful narrative, the film is a must-watch for fans of true-life dramas and Lifetime’s signature storytelling.
I Was Octomom: The Natalie Suleman Story Cast List
1- Kristen Lee Gutoskie as Natalie
Kristen Lee Gutoskie, born May 21, 1986, in Windsor, Canada, is a versatile actress known for her roles in Containment and The Vampire Diaries. In I Was Octomom, she takes on the challenging role of Natalie Suleman, capturing the complexity and vulnerability of a woman thrust into the global spotlight. Gutoskie’s portrayal highlights Natalie’s determination, resilience, and the emotional toll of her journey.
Gutoskie’s ability to convey both strength and fragility makes her a perfect fit for the role. Her performance anchors the film, offering a nuanced and empathetic portrayal of a woman who faced unimaginable challenges.
2- Caitlin Stryker as Beth
Caitlin Stryker, a talented actress known for her work in independent films and television, plays Beth, Natalie’s close friend and confidante. Stryker’s portrayal of Beth captures the character’s loyalty and support, as she stands by Natalie through the highs and lows of her journey.
Stryker’s performance adds warmth and depth to the film, as Beth’s friendship provides a source of strength for Natalie. Her character’s unwavering support highlights the importance of having a strong support system.
3- Anita Wittenberg as Angela
Anita Wittenberg, a seasoned actress known for her work in Supernatural and The Man in the High Castle, plays Angela, Natalie’s mother. Wittenberg’s portrayal of Angela captures the character’s concern and love for her daughter, as she navigates the challenges of supporting Natalie and her growing family.
Wittenberg’s ability to convey both toughness and compassion makes Angela a standout character. Her performance adds emotional depth to the film, as Angela’s relationship with Natalie reflects the complexities of family dynamics.
4- David Allan Pearson as Eddie
David Allan Pearson, known for his work in The Flash and Riverdale, plays Eddie, Natalie’s ex-husband. Pearson’s portrayal of Eddie captures the character’s struggles and regrets, as he grapples with his role in Natalie’s life and the challenges of co-parenting.
Pearson’s performance adds tension and complexity to the film, as Eddie’s relationship with Natalie evolves over time. His character’s journey reflects the challenges of navigating personal and familial responsibilities.
5- Jovanna Burke as Gail
Jovanna Burke, a rising actress known for her work in The Good Doctor and A Million Little Things, plays Gail, a social worker assigned to Natalie’s case. Burke’s portrayal of Gail captures the character’s professionalism and empathy, as she works to ensure the well-being of Natalie’s children.
Burke’s performance adds a layer of realism to the film, as Gail’s interactions with Natalie highlight the challenges of balancing compassion and accountability. Her character’s journey reflects the complexities of the social services system.
6- Miles Marthaller as Elijah (6 Years Old)
Miles Marthaller, a talented young actor, plays Elijah, one of Natalie’s children. Marthaller’s portrayal of Elijah captures the innocence and curiosity of a child growing up in a unique and challenging environment.
Detail: I Was Octomom: The Natalie Suleman Story (2025) cast, release date, plot, trailer
Marthaller’s performance adds heartwarming moments to the film, as Elijah’s interactions with his siblings and mother provide a glimpse into the joys and struggles of a large family.
7- Scarlett Tupper as Amerah (9 Years Old)
Scarlett Tupper, a rising young actress, plays Amerah, one of Natalie’s older children. Tupper’s portrayal of Amerah captures the character’s maturity and resilience, as she helps care for her younger siblings.
Tupper’s performance adds depth to the film, as Amerah’s journey reflects the responsibilities and challenges faced by children in large families. Her character’s strength and determination are a testament to the resilience of Natalie’s children.
8- Benjamin Jacobson as Elijah (10 Years Old)
Benjamin Jacobson, a talented young actor, plays Elijah at 10 years old. Jacobson’s portrayal of Elijah captures the character’s growth and development, as he navigates the challenges of growing up in a high-profile family.
Jacobson’s performance adds emotional depth to the film, as Elijah’s journey reflects the impact of Natalie’s choices on her children. His character’s resilience and adaptability are a highlight of the story.
9- Adam Beauchesne as Obstetrician
Adam Beauchesne, known for his work in The X-Files and Supernatural, plays the obstetrician who oversees Natalie’s pregnancy and delivery. Beauchesne’s portrayal of the obstetrician captures the character’s professionalism and concern, as he navigates the complexities of Natalie’s unprecedented pregnancy.
Beauchesne’s performance adds a layer of realism to the film, as the obstetrician’s role highlights the medical and ethical challenges of Natalie’s journey. His character’s interactions with Natalie provide insight into the pressures faced by medical professionals.
10- Lauren Akemi Bradley as Ann Curry
Lauren Akemi Bradley, a talented actress known for her work in The Man in the High Castle and The Good Doctor, plays Ann Curry, the journalist who interviews Natalie during her rise to fame. Bradley’s portrayal of Curry captures the character’s professionalism and empathy, as she seeks to tell Natalie’s story with integrity.
Bradley’s performance adds depth to the film, as Curry’s interviews provide a window into Natalie’s life and the media frenzy that surrounded her. Her character’s journey reflects the challenges of balancing journalistic ethics with public interest.
11- Genevieve Fleming as Lara
Genevieve Fleming, a rising actress, plays Lara, a journalist who covers Natalie’s story. Fleming’s portrayal of Lara captures the character’s ambition and curiosity, as she seeks to uncover the truth behind Natalie’s journey.
Fleming’s performance adds tension to the film, as Lara’s pursuit of the story highlights the impact of media scrutiny on Natalie’s life. Her character’s journey reflects the complexities of journalism in the age of sensationalism.
12- Kylee Bush as Jules
Kylee Bush, a talented young actress, plays Jules, one of Natalie’s children. Bush’s portrayal of Jules captures the character’s innocence and resilience, as she navigates the challenges of growing up in a large and high-profile family.
Bush’s performance adds heartwarming moments to the film, as Jules’s interactions with her siblings and mother provide a glimpse into the joys and struggles of family life.
