Premiering on Paramount+ on February 23, 2025, 1923 Season 2 continues the epic saga of the Dutton family’s fight to protect their Montana ranch amid the brutal challenges of the early 20th century. Set against the backdrop of Prohibition, drought, and the encroaching modern world, this Taylor Sheridan-helmed prequel to Yellowstone weaves together the fates of ranchers, indigenous communities, and lawmen in a raw, unflinching portrayal of survival. With the Duttons grappling with external threats and internal fractures, Season 2 delves deeper into the moral complexities of power, legacy, and resilience.
Featuring a powerhouse cast led by Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren, 1923 remains a cornerstone of Paramount+’s gritty storytelling. Let’s meet the stars bringing this sweeping historical drama to life.
Introducing the Cast of 1923 Season 2
1: Harrison Ford as Jacob Dutton
Harrison Ford, the legendary actor behind Indiana Jones and Star Wars, returns as Jacob Dutton, the hardened patriarch of the Yellowstone Ranch. Ford’s gruff charisma and weathered gravitas, honed in roles like Blade Runner 2049 (2017) and The Fugitive (1993), make Jacob the embodiment of stoic leadership in a lawless era.
In Season 2, Ford’s portrayal delves into Jacob’s vulnerabilities as age and violence take their toll. His chemistry with Helen Mirren crackles with decades of unspoken history, anchoring the series’ emotional core.
2: Helen Mirren as Cara Dutton
Dame Helen Mirren, Oscar winner for The Queen (2006), reprises her role as Cara Dutton, Jacob’s fiercely loyal wife. Mirren’s ability to balance steeliness and vulnerability, seen in The Last Station (2009) and Prime Suspect, elevates Cara into a matriarch for the ages.
Season 2 explores Cara’s past as an Irish immigrant, with Mirren delivering monologues that blend poetic grit and quiet sorrow. Her scenes with Ford are masterclasses in understated marital tension.
3: Brandon Sklenar as Spencer Dutton
Brandon Sklenar (The Offer, Vice) shines as Spencer Dutton, the war-scarred big-game hunter navigating love and duty. Sklenar’s brooding intensity, reminiscent of a young Brad Pitt, has made Spencer a fan favorite, with his African adventures offering a stark contrast to Montana’s bleakness.
In Season 2, Sklenar’s chemistry with Julia Schlaepfer deepens as Spencer’s relationship with Alexandra faces new trials. His physicality in action sequences cements him as the franchise’s next breakout star.
4: Julia Schlaepfer as Alexandra
Julia Schlaepfer (The Politician, Panic) returns as Alexandra, the British socialite who risks everything for her love of Spencer. Schlaepfer’s effervescent charm, seen in Netflix’s The Ultimatum: Queer Love, contrasts beautifully with the show’s grim tone.
Season 2 pushes Alexandra into the harsh realities of frontier life, with Schlaepfer showcasing her range as the character evolves from romantic idealist to resilient survivor.
5: Aminah Nieves as Teonna Rainwater
Aminah Nieves, a rising star of Indigenous heritage, delivers a breakout performance as Teonna Rainwater, a young Native woman fleeing a brutal boarding school. Nieves’ raw emotional depth, reminiscent of Lily Gladstone in Killers of the Flower Moon, anchors the series’ exploration of systemic oppression.
In Season 2, Teonna’s journey intertwines with the Duttons, with Nieves’ portrayal balancing fury and hope in a storyline that challenges the Western genre’s conventions.
6: Darren Mann as Jack Dutton
Darren Mann (Animal Kingdom, Giant Little Ones) plays Jack Dutton, the earnest rancher torn between family duty and personal desires. Mann’s everyman appeal and physicality, honed in sports dramas like Power Rangers (2017), make Jack the series’ moral compass.
Season 2 tests Jack’s loyalty to Elizabeth (Michelle Randolph), with Mann’s performance capturing the anguish of a man caught between love and legacy.
7: Michelle Randolph as Elizabeth Strafford
Michelle Randolph (Ski School, Queen of the South) portrays Elizabeth Strafford, Jack’s headstrong fiancée. Randolph’s blend of wit and determination, seen in A Snowy Day in Oakland (2022), adds modernity to Elizabeth’s frontier resilience.
In Season 2, Elizabeth’s role expands as she confronts the ranch’s harsh realities, with Randolph balancing vulnerability and grit in standout scenes with Mirren.
8: Sebastian Roché as Father Renaud
Sebastian Roché (The Man in the High Castle, Supernatural) returns as Father Renaud, the sadistic priest overseeing Teonna’s boarding school. Roché’s chilling portrayal, akin to his roles in The Originals, embodies colonialism’s cruelty.
Season 2 delves into Renaud’s backstory, with Roché’s performance adding layers to the character’s monstrous hypocrisy.
9: Jennifer Carpenter as Mamie Fossett
Jennifer Carpenter (Dexter, Limitless) joins the cast as Mamie Fossett, a shrewd businesswoman clashing with the Duttons. Carpenter’s knack for playing complex antiheroes, seen in The Enemy Within, makes Mamie a formidable adversary.
Her scenes with Ford crackle with tension, as Mamie’s ambitions threaten the Yellowstone’s future.
10: Augustus Prew as Paul
Augustus Prew (The Morning Show, Klaus) plays Paul, a charming but volatile drifter entangled in the Duttons’ struggles. Prew’s magnetic unpredictability, showcased in Kick-Ass 2 (2013), adds a wildcard energy to the ensemble.
In Season 2, Paul’s alliances shift unpredictably, with Prew’s performance keeping viewers guessing until the final frame.
With its blend of historical grandeur and intimate drama, 1923 Season 2 promises to be Paramount+’s most gripping chapter yet. Stream it on February 23, 2025—where the fight for the American West reaches a boiling point.
