Premiering May 3, 2025, on Lifetime, I Am Your Biggest Fan delves into the chilling story of Miranda (Denise Gossett), a beloved TV actress ensnared by a seemingly innocent admirer, Delilah (Meghan Carrasquillo), whose adoration spirals into a nightmarish captivity. This psychological thriller features a dynamic cast blending seasoned actors and fresh faces. Explore the careers and roles of the ensemble bringing this twisted narrative to life.
Cast of I Am Your Biggest Fan
1. Denise Gossett as Miranda
Denise Gossett, born in 1971, is an actress and filmmaker best known as the founder of the Shriekfest Film Festival, a platform for horror and thriller genres. Her acting credits include The Dead Matter (2010) and Dark Remains (2005), where her knack for suspense earned her a cult following. Beyond the screen, Gossett’s advocacy for indie filmmakers has made her a respected figure in the horror community.
As Miranda, Gossett channels her experience in thrillers to portray a star grappling with fame’s dark side. To prepare, she studied real-life cases of celebrity stalkers and collaborated with psychologists to capture Miranda’s descent from confidence to vulnerability. Off-screen, Gossett continues to champion indie horror through Shriekfest, proving life often mirrors art in its unpredictability.
2. Meghan Carrasquillo as Delilah
Meghan Carrasquillo, a rising young actor, steps into the spotlight as Delilah, Miranda’s deranged fan. Carrasquillo’s prior roles in short films like The Dollhouse (2023) showcased her ability to balance innocence with eerie intensity, making her a natural fit for this breakout role.
Carrasquillo worked closely with the director to explore Delilah’s fractured psyche, drawing inspiration from psychological thrillers. Her performance promises to haunt audiences, blurring the line between admiration and obsession.
3. Colton Tapp as Cody
Colton Tapp, born in 1998, gained recognition for roles in The Fosters (2015) and Criminal Minds (2016). His versatility in portraying troubled teens adds depth to Cody, Miranda’s loyal assistant caught in Delilah’s web.
Tapp’s preparation included researching celebrity entourage dynamics. Off-screen, he advocates for mental health awareness, a theme echoed in Cody’s struggle to protect Miranda.
4. J. Barrett Cooper as Barry
J. Barrett Cooper, known for The Walking Dead (2014) and Stranger Things (2017), brings rugged charm to Barry, Miranda’s skeptical manager. Born in Atlanta, Cooper’s background in Southern dramas informs Barry’s no-nonsense demeanor.
Cooper’s role required mastering the balance between cynicism and loyalty. Up next, he stars in the indie drama Broken Chains (2025), but I Am Your Biggest Fan highlights his knack for high-stakes tension.
5. Bryson JonSteele as Young Cody
Bryson JonSteele, a promising child actor, portrays Young Cody in flashbacks revealing Miranda’s rise to fame. His previous work in commercials and school plays laid the groundwork for his heartfelt performance.
JonSteele’s innocence contrasts starkly with the film’s darker themes, symbolizing Miranda’s lost simplicity.
6. Mark Valeriano as Nathan
Mark Valeriano, a character actor with credits in NCIS (2019) and Bosch (2020), plays Nathan, a journalist probing Miranda’s past. Valeriano’s gravitas adds intrigue to the role.
Valeriano drew from real investigative reporters’ tenacity, crafting Nathan as a man torn between truth and sensationalism.
7. Lauren Cole as Ellen
Lauren Cole, a stage-trained actor from Chicago, makes her TV debut as Ellen, Miranda’s estranged sister. Cole’s theater background in A Streetcar Named Desire (2022) informs Ellen’s emotional complexity.
Cole’s portrayal explores familial betrayal and reconciliation, themes she connects to her own close-knit family experiences.
8. Nancy Harding as Cynthia
Nancy Harding, known for General Hospital (2018–2021), embodies Cynthia, Miranda’s pragmatic publicist. Harding’s sharp wit and experience in daytime drama lend authenticity to the role.
Harding’s performance underscores the cutthroat nature of fame, a world she’s navigated both on- and off-screen.
9. Ed Formica as Waiter
Ed Formica, a veteran of indie films like Midnight Diner (2023), appears as a waiter pivotal to Miranda’s fate. His brief but crucial role required mastering subtle menace.
Formica’s background in improv comedy adds unpredictability to his interactions, leaving audiences uneasy.
10. Ayla Apple as Young Delilah
Ayla Apple, a child actor with a background in theater, plays Young Delilah in flashbacks hinting at her twisted psyche. Her role in The Secret Garden (2023) showcased her ability to convey hidden darkness.
Apple’s innocent appearance belies the character’s burgeoning instability, a duality she studied through child psychology resources.
11. Matt Fling as Jerry
Matt Fling, known for Chicago Fire (2020), portrays Jerry, a tech-savvy ally aiding Miranda’s escape. Fling’s everyman charm provides moments of levity amid tension.
Fling’s role required learning hacking basics, a skill he humorously admits “is now my party trick.”
12. Terry Quillen as Waiter
Terry Quillen, a background actor with over 50 credits, brings authenticity to a café waiter. His fleeting presence underscores the mundane world contrasting Miranda’s ordeal.
Quillen’s dedication to even minor roles reflects his belief that “every character has a story.”
13. Key Symone as Vanessa
Key Symone, a social media influencer turned actor, debuts as Vanessa, a fan-turned-ally. Symone’s online persona, focused on self-empowerment, mirrors Vanessa’s journey.
Symone’s transition to acting highlights her versatility, with Vanessa serving as a beacon of hope in the narrative.
14. Rodney Hagan as Cafe Patron
Rodney Hagan, a theater staple, appears as a café patron whose brief interaction with Miranda heightens the suspense. His stage experience in Wait Until Dark (2022) informs his tense cameo.
Hagan’s role, though small, exemplifies how ordinary moments can spiral into chaos.
15. Karra Robinson as Janey
Karra Robinson, known for Queen Sugar (2021), plays Janey, Miranda’s childhood friend. Robinson’s warmth provides a stark contrast to the film’s darker elements.
Robinson’s performance anchors Miranda’s humanity, reminding viewers of the life she fights to reclaim.
