Premiering on February 22, 2025, on Lifetime, My Amish Double Life is a gripping drama that explores the clash between tradition and modernity, faith and freedom. The film follows Emma (Lexi Minetree), a young Amish woman torn between her sheltered upbringing and the allure of the outside world.
When a shocking secret from her past resurfaces, Emma must navigate a web of lies, betrayal, and danger to protect her family and her future. With a heartfelt story of love, sacrifice, and self-discovery, My Amish Double Life promises to deliver the emotional depth and suspense that Lifetime viewers crave. Featuring a talented ensemble cast, this film is set to be a standout in the network’s lineup of compelling original movies.
Meet the Cast of My Amish Double Life:
1- Lexi Minetree as Emma
Lexi Minetree takes on the lead role of Emma, a young Amish woman grappling with her identity and the secrets that threaten to upend her life. Known for her work in indie films and heartfelt dramas, Minetree brings a quiet strength and emotional depth to her performances. Her ability to convey vulnerability and resilience makes her the perfect choice to portray Emma’s internal struggle between duty and desire.
As Emma, Minetree will navigate a complex emotional landscape, balancing her character’s devotion to her family with her yearning for independence. Her chemistry with co-stars like Ty Trumbo and Lesa Wilson will be crucial in bringing the film’s central relationships to life. Fans can expect a nuanced and moving performance that anchors the film’s emotional core.
2- Lesa Wilson as Mary
Lesa Wilson, a seasoned actress with a background in theater and television, plays Mary, Emma’s stern but loving mother. Wilson’s ability to portray strong, multifaceted women has made her a standout in projects like The Good Doctor (2017-2023) and Grey’s Anatomy (2005-present). As Mary, she embodies the tension between upholding tradition and understanding her daughter’s struggles.
Wilson’s performance will likely highlight the generational divide between Emma and her mother, adding depth to the film’s exploration of family dynamics. Her scenes with Minetree promise to be emotionally charged, offering a poignant look at the sacrifices parents make for their children.
3- Rachel Coopes as Rebecca
Rachel Coopes, known for her roles in Wentworth (2013-2021) and The Code (2014), brings her talent to the role of Rebecca, Emma’s confidante and fellow Amish woman. Coopes’ ability to balance warmth and strength makes Rebecca a relatable and supportive figure in Emma’s life.
As Rebecca, Coopes will likely provide both emotional support and moments of levity, offering a counterbalance to the film’s darker themes. Her performance will add richness to the story’s exploration of community and friendship.
4- Ty Trumbo as Heath
Ty Trumbo, a rising star known for his work in The Fosters (2013-2018) and Good Trouble (2019-present), plays Heath, an outsider who becomes entangled in Emma’s life. Trumbo’s charm and versatility make him a compelling romantic lead, and his chemistry with Minetree will be key to the film’s emotional stakes.
As Heath, Trumbo will navigate the complexities of love and loyalty, offering a fresh perspective on Emma’s world. His performance promises to be both heartfelt and dynamic, adding a layer of romance to the film’s suspenseful narrative.
5- Nick Clark as Caleb
Nick Clark, known for his roles in Chicago Fire (2012-present) and Empire (2015-2020), takes on the role of Caleb, Emma’s betrothed and a steadfast member of the Amish community. Clark’s ability to portray quiet strength and integrity makes Caleb a sympathetic and grounded character.
As Caleb, Clark will embody the values of tradition and faith, creating a compelling contrast to Heath’s outsider perspective. His performance will add depth to the film’s exploration of love and duty.
6- Gary Modlish as David
Gary Modlish, a veteran character actor known for The Blacklist (2013-present) and Law & Order: SVU (1999-present), plays David, a community elder with a hidden agenda. Modlish’s ability to portray authority and complexity makes David a fascinating and enigmatic figure.
As David, Modlish will likely serve as both a mentor and an antagonist, adding layers of intrigue to the story. His performance promises to be a standout, blending gravitas with subtle menace.
7- Adam Harper as Isaac
Adam Harper, known for The Walking Dead (2010-2022) and Ozark (2017-2022), takes on the role of Isaac, a troubled figure from Emma’s past. Harper’s ability to portray intensity and vulnerability makes Isaac a compelling and unpredictable character.
As Isaac, Harper will add tension and danger to the film’s narrative, creating a sense of urgency as Emma’s secrets come to light. His performance promises to be both gripping and emotionally resonant.
8- Ashley S. Evans as Det. Fisher
Ashley S. Evans, known for NCIS (2003-present) and Criminal Minds (2005-2020), plays Det. Fisher, a determined investigator drawn into Emma’s world. Evans’ ability to portray intelligence and empathy makes Fisher a relatable and driven character.
Detail: My Amish Double Life (2025) cast, release date, trailer, plot synopsis
As Det. Fisher, Evans will bring a sense of realism and urgency to the film’s suspenseful plot. Her performance will add a layer of procedural intrigue to the story.
9- Tashi Simmons as Det. Moreno
Tashi Simmons, known for SWAT (2017-present) and 9-1-1 (2018-present), plays Det. Moreno, Fisher’s partner and a sharp-witted investigator. Simmons’ ability to balance humor and intensity makes Moreno a dynamic and engaging character.
As Det. Moreno, Simmons will provide both levity and insight, adding depth to the film’s investigative subplot. Her chemistry with Evans promises to be a highlight of the film.
10- Dillon Peyerk as Carl
Dillon Peyerk, known for Shameless (2011-2021) and The Rookie (2018-present), plays Carl, a local with ties to Emma’s past. Peyerk’s ability to portray rugged charm and vulnerability makes Carl a compelling and sympathetic character.
As Carl, Peyerk will add a layer of complexity to the story, offering a glimpse into the challenges of life on the fringes of the Amish community. His performance promises to be both heartfelt and impactful.
11- Gregory M. Mitchell as Barry
Gregory M. Mitchell, known for This Is Us (2016-2022) and The Resident (2018-present), plays Barry, a businessman with a hidden connection to Emma’s story. Mitchell’s ability to portray ambition and moral ambiguity makes Barry a fascinating and unpredictable character.
As Barry, Mitchell will add a layer of intrigue to the film’s narrative, creating tension as his true motives are revealed. His performance promises to be both nuanced and compelling.
My Amish Double Life is a powerful exploration of identity, faith, and the bonds that tie us together. With a talented cast and a story full of twists and heart, this Lifetime original movie is set to captivate audiences when it premieres on February 22, 2025. Don’t miss it!
