The thrilling drama Playing With Fire is set to premiere on March 16, 2025, exclusively on Lifetime. This suspense-filled story follows Natalie Collins, a young woman whose life spirals out of control when she becomes entangled in a dangerous game of deception, betrayal, and revenge. As secrets from her past resurface, Natalie must confront her darkest fears and fight to protect herself and her loved ones. With its mix of emotional drama, shocking twists, and edge-of-your-seat tension, Playing With Fire is a must-watch for fans of Lifetime’s signature thrillers.
Featuring a talented ensemble cast, the film explores themes of trust, resilience, and the consequences of playing with fire. From explosive confrontations to unexpected alliances, Playing With Fire promises to keep viewers hooked until the very end.
Playing With Fire Cast Revealed: Meet the Stars
1- Kirsten Comerford as Natalie Collins
Kirsten Comerford, known for her roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), takes on the lead role of Natalie Collins, a young woman caught in a web of lies and danger. Comerford’s ability to convey vulnerability and strength makes her the perfect choice for this complex character.
Off-screen, Comerford is celebrated for her versatility in both drama and suspense, and her portrayal of Natalie—a woman pushed to her limits—adds a layer of intensity and heart to the film.
2- Stephen Adekolu as Jack
Stephen Adekolu, known for his roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Jack, Natalie’s charming yet enigmatic love interest. Adekolu’s ability to convey charm and menace makes him a standout in the film.
Adekolu’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased his range, and his performance in Playing With Fire promises to be equally compelling. Jack’s journey—from ally to potential antagonist—adds a layer of intrigue to the story.
3- Brett Geddes as Loughlin Collins
Brett Geddes, known for his roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Loughlin Collins, Natalie’s overprotective father. Geddes’s ability to convey authority and vulnerability makes him a standout in the film.
Geddes’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased his talent, and his performance in Playing With Fire is sure to leave a lasting impression. Loughlin’s journey—from protector to potential adversary—adds a layer of tension to the story.
4- Aury Barnett as Rick
Aury Barnett, known for his roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Rick, a mysterious figure with ties to Natalie’s past. Barnett’s ability to convey menace and vulnerability makes him a standout in the film.
Barnett’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased his talent, and his performance in Playing With Fire is sure to captivate audiences. Rick’s role—from outsider to central figure—adds a layer of intrigue to the story.
5- Shanna Armogan as Alesha
Shanna Armogan, known for her roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Alesha, Natalie’s loyal best friend. Armogan’s ability to convey warmth and resilience makes her a standout in the film.
Armogan’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased her talent, and her performance in Playing With Fire is sure to leave a lasting impression. Alesha’s journey—from supporter to potential victim—adds a layer of emotional depth to the story.
6- Rachel Sellan as Alison
Rachel Sellan, known for her roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Alison, a mysterious figure with ties to Natalie’s past. Sellan’s ability to convey menace and vulnerability makes her a standout in the film.
Sellan’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased her talent, and her performance in Playing With Fire is sure to captivate audiences. Alison’s role—from outsider to central figure—adds a layer of intrigue to the story.
7- Dean Hagopian as Mr. Benson
Dean Hagopian, known for his roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Mr. Benson, a powerful and influential figure with ties to Natalie’s past. Hagopian’s ability to convey authority and vulnerability makes him a standout in the film.
Hagopian’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased his talent, and his performance in Playing With Fire is sure to leave a lasting impression. Mr. Benson’s journey—from mentor to potential adversary—adds a layer of tension to the story.
8- Mich Ward as Mike
Mich Ward, known for his roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Mike, a brooding and mysterious figure with a hidden agenda. Ward’s ability to convey intensity and vulnerability makes him a standout in the film.
Ward’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased his talent, and his performance in Playing With Fire is sure to captivate audiences. Mike’s journey—from outsider to central figure—adds a layer of intrigue to the story.
9- Shannon McDonough as Mandy
Shannon McDonough, known for her roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Mandy, a mysterious figure with ties to Natalie’s past. McDonough’s ability to convey menace and vulnerability makes her a standout in the film.
McDonough’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased her talent, and her performance in Playing With Fire is sure to captivate audiences. Mandy’s role—from outsider to central figure—adds a layer of intrigue to the story.
10- Deklon Roberts as Tony
Deklon Roberts, known for his roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays Tony, a brooding and mysterious figure with a hidden agenda. Roberts’s ability to convey intensity and vulnerability makes him a standout in the film.
Roberts’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased his talent, and his performance in Playing With Fire is sure to captivate audiences. Tony’s journey—from outsider to central figure—adds a layer of intrigue to the story.
11- Patrick Publow as Party Goer
Patrick Publow, known for his roles in The Bold and the Beautiful (1987–present) and The Young and the Restless (1973–present), plays a party goer with ties to Natalie’s past. Publow’s ability to convey menace and vulnerability makes him a standout in the film.
Publow’s recent work in The Bay (2010–present) showcased his talent, and his performance in Playing With Fire is sure to captivate audiences. His character’s role in the story adds a layer of intrigue to the narrative.
Playing With Fire premieres March 16, 2025, on Lifetime—don’t miss this suspense-filled drama that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
