Lifetime’s upcoming thriller My Amish Double Life (2025) promises suspense, mystery, and a gripping tale of cultural clash. From its intriguing plot to its talented cast, here’s your ultimate guide to the film.
Release Date & Network
Mark your calendars! My Amish Double Life premieres February 22, 2025, exclusively on Lifetime. The movie will run for 1 hour and 25 minutes, making it a perfect weekend thriller.
Plot Synopsis: A Nightmare Behind the English Curtain
Emma (Lexi Minetree), a young Amish woman reeling from her father’s mysterious death, yearns to escape her sheltered life. Defying her mother Mary (Lesa Wilson), she embarks on a rumspringa—a traditional Amish rite of passage—with the help of her friend Rebecca (Rachel Coopes).
In the “English” world, Emma meets Heath (Ty Trumbo), a charming stranger who sweeps her off her feet. But their whirlwind romance takes a dark turn when Heath abruptly leaves for a work emergency, leaving Emma alone in his modern home. Her curiosity turns to horror when she discovers a dead body in the kitchen and is knocked unconscious by a shadowy figure.
Waking with no proof of the crime, Emma flees back to her Amish community, hoping to hide from the nightmare. But when detectives Fisher (Ashley S. Evans) and Moreno (Tashi Simmons) arrive with questions, she realizes she must solve the murder herself—before the killer silences her for good.
Cast & Characters
- Lexi Minetree as Emma: A brave Amish woman thrust into a dangerous mystery.
- Lesa Wilson as Mary: Emma’s protective mother, wary of the outside world.
- Rachel Coopes as Rebecca: Emma’s loyal friend who aids her escape.
- Ty Trumbo as Heath: Emma’s enigmatic love interest with secrets of his own.
- Ashley S. Evans & Tashi Simmons as Detectives Fisher & Moreno: The duo investigating the murder.
Supporting Cast: Nick Clark (Caleb), Gary Modlish (David), Adam Harper (Isaac), Dillon Peyerk (Carl), and Charles Christopher (Elder Zeke).
Behind the Scenes
- Director: Cooper Harrington
- Writers: Bryan Dick, Ken Sanders, John J. Tierney
- Filming Locations: Shot in Alpharetta, Georgia, blending rustic Amish settings with modern backdrops.
- Alternate Titles: My Amish Double Life Lifetime, My Amish Double Life movie.
Trailer & Where to Watch
While the official trailer has yet to drop, expect suspenseful teasers closer to the release date. Stay tuned to Lifetime’s YouTube channel and social media for updates.
Where to Watch: Stream the movie live on Lifetime or catch it later on Lifetime’s streaming platform.
FAQ
1. What time does My Amish Double Life air?
Lifetime typically airs original movies at 8/7c, but check local listings as the premiere approaches.
2. Will there be a Part 2?
No official confirmation yet! A sequel will likely depend on the film’s reception and unresolved plot threads.
3. What to expect from the movie?
A tense blend of Amish tradition vs. modern chaos, with twists, romance, and a race against time. Think Harrison Ford meets Plain Truth!
With its mix of cultural drama and edge-of-your-seat thrills, My Amish Double Life is poised to be a standout Lifetime thriller. Will Emma uncover the killer—or become the next victim? Tune in on February 22, 2025, to find out.
