Get ready for a thrilling escape to Mystery Island: Winner Takes All, premiering March 13, 2025, on Hallmark Mystery! This captivating new series combines sun-soaked intrigue with a deadly twist, as a lavish island getaway turns into a high-stakes game of secrets, betrayal, and survival. With its mix of tropical glamour and pulse-pounding mystery, the show promises to keep viewers guessing until the final clue is uncovered.
Leading the cast are three dynamic actors whose characters must navigate a web of lies, alliances, and hidden motives. From a charismatic socialite to a brilliant doctor and a sharp-witted detective, the ensemble brings depth and suspense to this paradise-turned-nightmare.
Mystery Island: Winner Takes All’s Leading Cast: Who’s Who?
1- Kristin Booth as Cassandra
Kristin Booth, a Hallmark fan favorite known for Good Witch and Signed, Sealed, Delivered, takes on the role of Cassandra, a charming yet enigmatic socialite with a knack for staying one step ahead of everyone. Cassandra’s lavish lifestyle masks a cunning mind, and her motives for joining the island retreat are as mysterious as the puzzles surrounding it.
Booth’s extensive experience in blending warmth with intrigue makes her perfect for this role. Off-screen, she’s celebrated for her versatility in both heartfelt dramas and lighthearted mysteries, ensuring Cassandra will be a character viewers love to unravel.
2- Elizabeth Henstridge as Dr. Emilia Priestly
Elizabeth Henstridge, best known as Agent Jemma Simmons in Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., stars as Dr. Emilia Priestly, a brilliant epidemiologist whose expertise is unexpectedly tested when the island’s guests begin falling ill—or worse. Emilia’s scientific rigor clashes with the chaos around her, but her determination to uncover the truth could be the key to survival.
Henstridge’s background in balancing intellect with emotional depth shines in this role. Her transition from sci-fi hero to medical sleuth adds fresh layers to her career, making Emilia a standout character in the mystery genre.
3- Charlie Weber as Detective Charlie Weber
Charlie Weber, famed for his role as Frank Delfino in How to Get Away with Murder, steps into the shoes of Detective Charlie Weber, a sharp, no-nonsense investigator who finds himself trapped in the game he’s meant to solve. His street-smart instincts and unyielding resolve make him a formidable force—but even he may not be prepared for the island’s twisted secrets.
Weber’s knack for portraying brooding intensity with a touch of vulnerability ensures Detective Weber is more than a typical tough cop. His chemistry with the cast and ability to navigate moral gray areas will keep audiences hooked.
Mystery Island: Winner Takes All premieres March 13, 2025, on Hallmark Mystery—don’t miss this addictive blend of tropical allure and edge-of-your-seat suspense.
