Premiering September 4, 2025, on LMN

In the wake of a painful and messy divorce, Ava Westcott (Kirsten Comerford) seeks solace and a fresh start with a rejuvenating trip to Niagara Falls, accompanied by her steadfast best friend. The majestic beauty and roaring power of the falls promise a much-needed escape from her troubles, but tranquility quickly gives way to terror when she meets Wyatt Ross (Jon McLaren), a charming and handsome stranger who seems too good to be true. Their whirlwind romance under the mist of the falls soon reveals sinister cracks, as Ava discovers that Wyatt may be hiding a dark and dangerous secret.

What begins as a romantic getaway spirals into a psychological thriller filled with twists and turns. Ava’s quest for healing and connection becomes a desperate fight for survival as she uncovers the truth about the enigmatic man she trusted. With her best friend by her side, she must navigate a web of lies, deception, and hidden motives, where every smile could be a mask and every kindness a calculated move. Not So Perfect Strangers is a gripping tale of love, betrayal, and the terrifying reality that sometimes the greatest dangers come from those who seem the most perfect.

---

Not So Perfect Stranger Cast real names

1: Kirsten Comerford as Ava Westcott

Kirsten Comerford delivers a powerful performance as Ava Westcott, a woman rebuilding her life after a devastating divorce. Comerford masterfully portrays Ava’s vulnerability and strength, capturing her initial hope for a fresh start and her growing unease as Wyatt’s true nature begins to surface. Her journey from a heartbroken divorcee to a determined survivor forms the emotional core of the film, making her a relatable and resilient heroine.

Comerford’s ability to convey fear, suspicion, and courage adds depth to Ava’s character, drawing viewers into her terrifying predicament. Her chemistry with Jon McLaren is electric, blending romance and tension in equal measure. As Ava digs deeper into Wyatt’s secrets, Comerford ensures that every revelation hits with emotional impact, keeping audiences on the edge of their seats.

2: Jon McLaren as Wyatt Ross

Jon McLaren is captivating as Wyatt Ross, the charming and mysterious stranger who sweeps Ava off her feet. McLaren brings a magnetic presence to the role, balancing Wyatt’s allure with an undercurrent of menace that keeps everyone guessing. His performance is layered with subtle hints of deception, making it clear that Wyatt is far more than the ideal romantic partner he appears to be.

McLaren’s portrayal of Wyatt’s dual nature is both seductive and chilling. He effortlessly switches between tender moments and eerie intensity, creating a villain who is as unpredictable as he is dangerous. His chemistry with Kirsten Comerford fuels the film’s suspense, making their relationship a thrilling and unsettling centerpiece.

3: Catherine Saindon as Kirsten

Catherine Saindon shines as Kirsten, Ava’s loyal and pragmatic best friend who joins her on the trip to Niagara Falls. Saindon brings warmth and humor to the role, providing much-needed comic relief and emotional support amidst the rising tension. Kirsten’s skepticism about Wyatt adds a voice of reason, often clashing with Ava’s rose-colored view of her new romance.

Saindon’s performance highlights the importance of friendship and trust in the face of danger. Her character’s unwavering loyalty and sharp instincts make her an invaluable ally for Ava as the mystery deepens. Saindon’s chemistry with Comerford feels authentic and heartfelt, grounding the film in a relatable bond that viewers will root for.

4: Stanley Cooper as Thomas

Stanley Cooper appears as Thomas, a friendly local resident who becomes an unexpected source of information and assistance for Ava and Kirsten. Cooper brings a gentle, grounded presence to the role, offering a contrast to the glamour and deception surrounding Wyatt. Thomas’s knowledge of the area and its history proves crucial in uncovering the truth.

Cooper’s performance adds a layer of authenticity to the Niagara Falls setting. His character’s willingness to help showcases the kindness of strangers, even as danger lurks nearby. Thomas serves as a reminder that not everyone in this picturesque town has hidden motives, and his involvement raises the stakes for Ava’s investigation.

5: Tomas Chovanec as Officer Grady

Tomas Chovanec portrays Officer Grady, a diligent and empathetic local police officer who becomes involved in the unfolding mystery. Chovanec brings authority and compassion to the role, representing the law in a town where appearances can be deceiving. Officer Grady’s interactions with Ava and Kirsten add a procedural element to the thriller, as he pieces together the clues they uncover.

Chovanec’s performance balances professionalism with a growing concern for the women’s safety. His character’s determination to uncover the truth provides a sense of hope and justice amidst the chaos. Officer Grady’s presence ensures that the danger feels real and immediate, raising the stakes for everyone involved.

6: Debra Hale as Norah

Debra Hale delivers a memorable performance as Norah, a mysterious and reclusive figure with connections to Wyatt’s past. Hale brings an eerie and enigmatic energy to the role, keeping viewers guessing about Norah’s true intentions. Her character’s cryptic warnings and knowledge of local secrets make her a pivotal figure in Ava’s quest for the truth.

Hale’s portrayal of Norah is haunting and layered, blending vulnerability with an unsettling intensity. Her scenes are filled with suspense, as Ava and Kirsten struggle to determine whether she is an ally or another obstacle in their path. Norah’s presence deepens the mystery, adding twists that will leave audiences questioning everyone’s motives.

7: Jinesea Bianca Lewis as Ginny

Jinesea Bianca Lewis appears as Ginny, a vibrant and perceptive staff member at the hotel where Ava and Kirsten are staying. Lewis brings energy and charm to the role, making Ginny a friendly face in an increasingly hostile environment. Her observations and willingness to help provide Ava with critical insights into Wyatt’s behavior.

Lewis’s performance adds a touch of lightness and relatability to the thriller. Ginny’s camaraderie with Ava and Kirsten highlights the importance of community and trust, even in the most terrifying circumstances. Her character’s bravery and resourcefulness make her an unsung hero in the story.

8: Gregory Wilson as Reid

Gregory Wilson is compelling as Reid, a charismatic but suspicious acquaintance of Wyatt’s who seems to know more than he lets on. Wilson brings a slick and calculating presence to the role, creating a character whose friendly demeanor masks darker intentions. Reid’s interactions with Wyatt and Ava add layers of complexity to the central mystery.

Wilson’s performance keeps viewers on edge, as Reid’s loyalties remain ambiguous throughout the film. His character’s involvement suggests a wider web of deception, making it clear that Wyatt’s secrets are part of something much larger and more dangerous. Reid is a wildcard whose actions could either help or hinder Ava’s search for the truth.

9: Deklon Roberts as Officer McKibbon

Deklon Roberts rounds out the cast as Officer McKibbon, a no-nonsense and experienced police colleague of Officer Grady. Roberts brings a grounded and pragmatic energy to the role, emphasizing the seriousness of the investigation. Officer McKibbon’s skepticism and methodical approach provide a counterbalance to Grady’s empathy, ensuring that every angle is explored.

Roberts’s performance adds depth to the law enforcement perspective, highlighting the challenges of solving a case where nothing is as it seems. His character’s dedication to justice reinforces the film’s themes of truth and redemption, making the resolution feel earned and satisfying.

---

Why Not So Perfect Strangers Is a Must-Watch

• Twists and Turns: A plot filled with unexpected revelations that will keep you guessing until the very end.

• Stunning Setting: The majestic and ominous backdrop of Niagara Falls adds a unique atmosphere to the thriller.

• Strong Performances: A talented cast brings depth and authenticity to this tale of love and deception.

• Relatable Themes: Explores trust, friendship, and the courage to uncover the truth, no matter the cost.

Don’t Miss the Premiere!

Not So Perfect Strangers premieres September 4, 2025, on LMN. Prepare for a rollercoaster of romance, suspense, and shocking secrets.