Prepare for a chilling tale of maternal instinct and suspicion when “She Wants My Daughter” premieres on LMN on September 19, 2025. This gripping psychological thriller follows Claire, a mother who begins to see her greatest blessing—her adopted daughter, Jenna—become the target of a potential nightmare. The family’s world is turned upside down when Jenna reconnects with her birth mother, Sara, through a popular DNA website. What begins as a beautiful story of reunion and answered questions quickly turns sinister as Sara ingratiates herself deeper into their lives. Claire’s initial unease blossoms into full-blown terror as she becomes convinced that Sara has a hidden, dangerous agenda that threatens to tear her family apart forever.

Anchoring this tense, domestic nightmare is a cast adept at portraying complex family dynamics and underlying menace. Alison Chace stars as the protective adoptive mother, Claire, while Jordan Lane Price takes on the enigmatic role of Sara, the birth mother. They are joined by Leann Gardner as the daughter caught in the middle, and a supporting ensemble including Jamie Ragusa and Justin C. Schilling. “She Wants My Daughter” promises to be a pulse-pounding exploration of nature versus nurture, trust, and the terrifying possibility that a stranger is hiding in plain sight.

She Wants My Daughter cast and characters breakdown

1- Alison Chace as Claire

Alison Chace headlines the film as Claire, the adoptive mother whose world is shattered by a seemingly joyous reunion. Chace’s performance will be a masterclass in escalating paranoia and fierce maternal protection. She must portray a woman who is initially supportive of her daughter’s curiosity about her roots, then gradually becomes isolated in her growing suspicions. Claire is likely painted by others as jealous or overprotective, forcing her to investigate Sara’s motives alone, questioning her own sanity in the process.

Chace embodies the core conflict of the film: is Claire’s fear a valid maternal instinct or the product of insecurity and jealousy? Her journey is one of transformation from a trusting, happy mother to a determined investigator willing to risk her own reputation to save her daughter from a threat only she can see. Chace’s ability to convey vulnerability, intelligence, and relentless determination will make Claire a relatable and compelling heroine for audiences to root for.

2- Jordan Lane Price as Sara

Jordan Lane Price takes on the complex and duplicitous role of Sara, the birth mother who re-enters her biological daughter’s life. Price’s task is to craft a character who is both charmingly sympathetic and subtly menacing. She must be believable as a woman seeking redemption and connection, all while leaving just enough of a trace of something darker lurking beneath the surface to validate Claire’s fears. Her performance will keep the audience guessing about her true intentions until the very end.

Price’s Sara is the catalyst for all the film’s tension. Is she a wounded soul looking for a second chance, or a master manipulator with a sinister long-game? Her ability to win over everyone except Claire makes her a formidable and intelligent antagonist. Price will skillfully navigate the character’s dual nature, using a warm smile that doesn’t quite reach her eyes or a comment that feels just a little too pointed, creating a deeply unsettling and unforgettable villain.

3- Leann Gardner as Jenna

Leann Gardner stars as Jenna, the adopted daughter who becomes the unwitting prize in a silent war between two mothers. Gardner’s role is crucial as she must portray a teenager experiencing the emotional whirlwind of meeting her birth mother for the first time. She is naturally curious, grateful to her adoptive parents, but also drawn to the biological connection and the exciting new presence of Sara, who may represent a part of her identity she’s always longed to understand.

Gardner’s performance will generate much of the film’s emotional drama and tension. Jenna is caught in the middle, often viewing her adoptive mother’s concerns as an attempt to control her or stifle this new relationship. Gardner must make the audience feel Jenna’s conflict, her desire for connection, and her gradual realization that the situation may not be as perfect as it seems, making her a sympathetic figure whose safety is the driving stake of the entire narrative.

4- Jamie Ragusa as Detective Russo

Jamie Ragusa joins the cast as Detective Russo, who likely becomes involved as Claire’s suspicions lead her to seek official help. Ragusa’s character represents the cold light of law and order contrasting with Claire’s emotional turmoil. Detective Russo probably begins as a skeptic, hearing the concerns of a worried mother with no concrete evidence of a crime, forcing Claire to prove her case.

Ragusa’s role adds a layer of procedural tension to the psychological thriller. Detective Russo is the reality check, the person who demands proof over paranoia. His involvement raises the stakes, signaling that the situation is escalating towards a potentially dangerous conclusion. Whether he becomes an ally or a obstacle for Claire is a key part of the plot’s progression.

5- Justin C. Schilling as Marcus

Justin C. Schilling appears as Marcus, who is most likely Claire’s husband and Jenna’s adoptive father. Schilling’s character is pivotal in the family dynamic, often serving as the voice of reason who is initially won over by Sara’s charm. He may dismiss Claire’s early concerns, creating marital strife and further isolating her, which is a common and effective trope in the genre that heightens the protagonist’s vulnerability.

Schilling’s performance will capture the frustration of a man trying to keep his family together and happy, unable to see the threat his wife perceives. His arc likely involves a painful awakening to the truth, forcing him to choose sides and ultimately support his wife in a desperate fight to protect their daughter. He represents the familial trust that is systematically eroded by Sara’s manipulation.

– The Supporting Network: Friends and Suspects

The film is bolstered by a network of characters who flesh out the world and add layers of suspicion. Kisha Barr plays Melissa, who could be Claire’s best friend and confidante, offering a shoulder to cry on but potentially doubting her story. Lucie Fleming (Elana) and Elana A. Mugdan (Kara) might be friends of Jenna’s or part of Sara’s past, their interactions providing clues or red herrings.

T.L. Flint rounds out the cast as Lenny, a character who could be a co-worker, a neighbor, or someone from Sara’s history who holds a key to uncovering her true motives. Each supporting role is designed to apply pressure to Claire, either as an unwitting accomplice to Sara’s scheme or as a potential source of crucial information that can help her expose the truth before it’s too late.