Carol (Stacey Dash) thinks she’s landed her dream job working alongside the charming Dr. Unger (Charisma Carpenter) – until she discovers his treatment plans come with a 100% mortality rate. This pulse-pounding medical thriller serves equal parts romance and cyanide, proving that sometimes the hottest doctors have the coldest hearts.

From Buffy alumni to soap opera royalty, this cast delivers the perfect cocktail of charm and menace. They’ll make you check your doctor’s credentials twice before your next checkup.

The Doctor With Two Faces complete cast list

1: Stacey Dash as CAROL

The Clueless star reinvents herself as our wide-eyed heroine, bringing back that iconic optimistic spark – now with added survival instincts. Watch how Dash subtly shifts Carol from adoring colleague to terrified investigator, her bubbly demeanor hardening with each discovered body.

Dash’s genius lies in her expressive reactions. That moment when she finds the “patient recovery rate” spreadsheet with a suspicious 0% column? Her face cycles through denial, horror, and determination in 3.2 seconds flat.

2: Charisma Carpenter as DR. JOAN UNGER

Buffy’s Cordelia Chase trades quips for scalpels in a career-redefining performance. Carpenter’s Unger is all polished perfection – until her eyes flash with something darker during late-night rounds. The way she says “Trust me, I’m a doctor” will make your blood run cold.

Carpenter masterfully balances charm and psychosis. Her romantic chemistry with Dash makes the betrayal cut deeper – when she delivers the line “You were my favorite nurse” while loading a syringe, it’s both heartbreaking and terrifying.

3: Masiela Lusha as SHEYLA

The George Lopez alum shines as the hospital’s no-nonsense administrator who notices odd medication orders. Lusha brings whip-smart intensity to every scene – especially when confronting Carpenter in the pharmacy, where her Albanian accent thickens with rage.

Watch for Sheyla’s brilliant deduction scene. As she connects patient deaths to Unger’s shifts, Lusha’s performance turns the hospital whiteboard into the most suspenseful prop of 2025.

4: Jonathan Stoddard as DR. DEREK CALICO

The Days of Our Lives star plays the hospital’s golden boy – until he questions one too many “accidental” overdoses. Stoddard’s trademark earnestness makes his character’s fate especially devastating (hint: never accept coffee from your suspicious colleague).

His romantic subplot with Dash adds delicious tension. That scene where he almost discovers Unger’s secret, only to be interrupted by a code blue? Soap opera fans will scream at their screens.

5: Eric Lutes as DR. MORRIS

The Caroline in the City veteran steals scenes as the hospital’s oblivious chief of staff. Lutes delivers every clueless line with perfect comedic timing – especially when praising Unger’s “impressive” patient turnover rate.

His obliviousness becomes darkly funny. The moment he casually mentions the morgue expansion while eating pudding? Comedy gold amidst the carnage.

6: Ava Gaudet as ANGIE

Gaudet (General Hospital) plays Carol’s sarcastic best friend/nurse – the voice of reason who notices everything (including that cute intern’s suspicious disappearance). Her deadpan one-liners provide much-needed levity between murders.

Her texting scenes are genius. Watching Gaudet react to Dash’s increasingly panicked messages (“He just prescribed arsenic???” “Like… for rats or…?”) is a masterclass in comedic timing.

7: Daniel L. Rivera as GRANT

The hunky intern who may or may not be in on the killings. Rivera keeps us guessing – is his character’s interest in Carol genuine, or is he covering for his mentor? That ambiguous smile after finding a missing patient’s chart? Chilling.

His fight scene with Stoddard (over both medicine and Dash’s affections) is reportedly one of LMN’s most intense hallway confrontations ever filmed.

8: Sarah Sweeney as NURSE

The scene-stealing background player who notices everything but stays wisely quiet. Sweeney’s expressive eyes tell entire stories – watch her slowly stop making eye contact with Unger as the body count rises.

Her single line “Code Blue… again?” delivered with exhausted dread, might be the most relatable moment in the film.

9: Tom Glynn as POLICE

Glynn brings gruff authority as the detective who thinks Carol is watching too much TV… until the autopsy reports come in. His gradual shift from skepticism to horror mirrors the audience’s journey.

That interrogation scene where Carpenter flirts her way out of suspicion? Glynn’s barely-contained eye roll should win awards.

10: Herlín Areniello as DR. LAURA MONROE

The wildcard – a brilliant new doctor whose arrival coincides with the killings stopping… or just changing methods? Areniello keeps us guessing whether she’s savior or accomplice.

Her final confrontation with Carpenter (complete with surgical tools as weapons) is being called LMN’s best catfight since Sleeping With My Student’s Mother.