In a quiet suburban town where secrets fester behind picket fences, The Perfect Killer delivers a spine-tingling thriller about a methodical murderer who leaves no trace—except for cryptic clues taunting the investigators. When Alyssa Price (Kirsten Comerford), a reclusive true-crime podcaster, stumbles upon a pattern linking unsolved deaths, she becomes the killer’s next obsession.
As paranoia tightens its grip, Detective Mila Gibson (JaNae Armogan) races against time to decode the killer’s twisted game, where every survivor is a pawn and every misstep could be fatal. Directed by suspense maestro Lydia Cole (Veiled Truth), this LMN Original blends razor-sharp tension with psychological depth, promising a finale that will leave viewers questioning every shadow.
The Perfect Killer Cast: Get to Know Them
1. Kirsten Comerford as Alyssa Price
Kirsten Comerford (born March 12, 1992) brings haunting intensity to Alyssa, a podcaster whose obsession with cold cases blurs the line between hunter and prey. Known for her roles in indie thrillers like Shadow of Doubt (2022) and Echoes of Silence (2023), Comerford excels at portraying women teetering on the edge of obsession. Her stage work in The Glass Menagerie (2021) earned critical praise for its raw vulnerability, a trait she channels into Alyssa’s relentless pursuit of truth.
Off-screen, Comerford advocates for mental health awareness, drawing from her own experiences with anxiety. “Alyssa isn’t just solving crimes—she’s running from herself,” she reveals. This role marks her first lead in a network thriller, showcasing her ability to balance fragility and ferocity.
2. JaNae Armogan as Mila Gibson
JaNae Armogan (born August 8, 1988), a rising star in crime dramas, commands the screen as Detective Mila Gibson. After standout roles in City Lights (2020) and Crime Alley (2023), Armogan’s portrayal of a detective battling institutional sexism adds grit to the procedural genre. Her theater roots (A Raisin in the Sun, 2019) inform Mila’s moral complexity and quiet resilience.
Armogan trained with real homicide detectives to perfect Mila’s steely demeanor. “She’s a puzzle solver in a world that keeps changing the pieces,” she says. A vocal supporter of women in law enforcement, Armogan’s performance is both a tribute and a critique of the system.
3. Sayla de Goede as Rebecca Brady
Sayla de Goede (born November 5, 1995), known for her supporting roles in Northern Vows (2021) and Frostbite (2022), plays Rebecca, Alyssa’s estranged sister harboring dark secrets. De Goede’s knack for layered performances shines as Rebecca oscillates between ally and suspect.
Detail: The Perfect Killer cast, release date, and everything you need to know
A graduate of Vancouver’s Film Arts Program, de Goede infuses Rebecca with simmering tension. “Family secrets are the deadliest,” she teases. Off-camera, she mentors young actors in underserved communities.
4. David Pinard as Officer Ferguson
David Pinard (born February 14, 1986), a staple in police procedurals like Borderline Justice (2021–2023), embodies Officer Ferguson, a small-town cop torn between duty and doubt. Pinard’s rugged authenticity, honed in Quebecois crime series Noir (2019), grounds the film’s escalating chaos.
Pinard’s off-screen passion for martial arts (he holds a black belt) informs Ferguson’s physicality. “He’s a good man in a world where good isn’t enough,” Pinard reflects.
5. Ben Steele Caldwell as Matthew
Ben Steele Caldwell (born July 30, 1997), an indie film favorite (Broken Circuits, 2023), delivers a breakout performance as Matthew, the enigmatic neighbor with a suspicious past. Caldwell’s background in improv comedy (Second City Toronto) adds unpredictability to his chilling portrayal.
“Matthew thrives in the gray areas,” Caldwell says. A climate activist, he parallels his character’s duality: “Even heroes have shadows.”
6. Lora Burke as Melody Cambridge
Lora Burke (born October 31, 1989), horror icon (Poor Agnes, 2017), terrifies as Melody, a reclusive artist with ties to the killer. Burke’s ability to blend menace and melancholy makes Melody a standout antagonist.
Burke studied abstract painting to prepare, calling Melody “a canvas of chaos.” Off-screen, she champions LGBTQ+ representation in horror.
7. Erica Deutschman as Olivia
Erica Deutschman (born April 9, 1993), a theater virtuoso (Macbeth, 2022), plays Olivia, a grieving widow entangled in the killer’s web. Deutschman’s stage-trained expressiveness amplifies Olivia’s descent into paranoia.
“Olivia’s grief is her prison,” Deutschman explains. An advocate for mental health, she brings visceral authenticity to the role.
8. Jean-Paul Najm as Tim Robertson
Jean-Paul Najm (born December 3, 1985), known for The Agency (2021), portrays Tim, a tech mogul with sinister connections. Najm’s suave yet menacing demeanor, seen in Corporate Lies (2023), heightens the film’s corporate conspiracy angle.
Najm, a former programmer, based Tim on Silicon Valley’s “disruptors.” “Innovation has a dark side,” he warns.
9. Laura Provenzano as Charlie Gibson
Laura Provenzano (born June 20, 1990), Riverdale alum, plays Charlie, Mila’s rebellious niece. Provenzano’s Gen-Z edge and roles in Skate or Die (2022) fuel Charlie’s tech-savvy, rule-breaking persona.
“Charlie’s the wildcard who hacks the system,” Provenzano says. A feminist activist, she pushed for Charlie’s agency in the plot.
10. Tomas Chovanec as Harrison
Tomas Chovanec (born September 8, 1982), Slovakian-Canadian actor (Cold Pursuit, 2019), chills as Harrison, a mercenary with a personal vendetta. Chovanec’s fluency in five languages adds global menace to the role.
“Harrison doesn’t hunt—he exterminates,” Chovanec states. A former athlete, he performed all his own stunts.
11. Tonjha Richardson as Detective Faulkner
Tonjha Richardson (born January 15, 1978), Rookie Blue veteran, brings gravitas as Faulkner, Mila’s skeptical superior. Richardson’s nuanced portrayal of authority figures (Transplant, 2020–2023) adds depth to Faulkner’s arc.
“Faulkner’s by-the-book until the book burns,” Richardson says. Off-screen, he mentors Black actors in Toronto.
12. Jason Reilly as Jack Gibson
Jason Reilly (born May 5, 1985), Heartland star, plays Jack, Mila’s estranged husband. Reilly’s trademark warmth masks Jack’s hidden agendas, creating a marital dynamic ripe with tension.
“Jack’s a storm in a teacup,” Reilly hints. A horseback rider in real life, he insisted on authentic emotional stakes.
Why The Perfect Killer Thrills
With a cast that masterfully balances suspense and humanity, The Perfect Killer is LMN’s most gripping original yet. Don’t miss the premiere on February 28, 2025—where every clue counts, and trust is the deadliest gamble.
